Makerspaces in Elementary Schools

    A makerspace is a dedicated area where students can use hands-on activities and tools to create something new, solve problems, and develop life-long skills (Arts Integration, 2023). It does not always have to be a physical space if there is no such space available, but can also be a mentality of setting aside time to create, explore, and learn (Anderson, 2023). While a makerspace can include STEM activities, it does not necessarily have to be STEM activities. The two go hand-in-hand, but can be kept separate from each other (Anderson, 2023). Makerspaces can include materials as simple as paper towel rolls, tissues, and tape, to as complex as 3D printers and iPads. Successful makerspaces have three elements in common. The first is that they "promote learning through play and experimentation," the second is that they are "cross-disciplinary, with elements of art, science, and craftsmanship," and the third is that they "offer tools and materials that encourage students to create rather than consume" (Krueger, 2022). 
    There are many benefits to incorporating makerspaces in school settings. The first is that it encourages creativity and innovation. While there may be some guidance for certain activities, students ultimately have the freedom to create what they want and to try out different things that they may not have had the opportunity to do in regular subjects in the classroom (Robbin, 2020). The second is that it requires students to experiment and revise their experiments many times in order to get the product that they are looking for. They will have to analyze problems to find solutions, collaborate with other classmates, listen to feedback, and find ways to improve, which are great 21st century skills for students to develop (Robbin, 2020). The third benefit is collaboration. Students learn how to work together in groups, how to design projects, communicate with one another, and accept feedback (Robbin, 2020). The fourth benefit is the development of resilience in students. Makerspaces are not meant to be easy, and students will learn that they need to change and adapt what they are working on and solve problems in order to be successful in what they are doing, which creates resilience (Robbin, 2020). 
    When a teacher is ready to create a makerspace in their elementary school the first thing they should consider is where the makerspace will be held. Is there any extra room in the school that can be used? As elementary teachers can you dedicate a portion of your classroom for makerspace activities with your students? Where will you store the materials? Once these questions have been answered you can then look for how to fund your makerspace. Elementary parents often have leftover craft supplies, legos, toys, broken electronics, or other materials that can be donated for a makerspace. Teachers can also seek support and funding from outside organizations like businesses or arts groups (Robbin, 2020). While it is great to have expensive technology and electronics like 3D printers for makerspaces, they are not required, and you can still have a makerspace without the price tag attached. Once you have the space and the materials you must come up with your intentions and goals for how the space will be used. Do you want students to create specific projects? Is it just a place of discovery and creativity? Answering these questions will determine how you use the space, how you set it up, and what specific materials you will need to run it (Arts Integration, 2023). 
    At the elementary level, too much freedom can be overwhelming and there will be many kids who do not know where to start (Krueger, 2022). They will need some sort of structure to begin creating and exploring. One way to do this is by providing simple materials. High-tech equipment and complicated materials will be more overwhelming to elementary aged students, when they would be just as satisfied with some paper and tape (Anderson, 2023). Another way to do this is through choice cards. Create a series of cards with multiple choices on what project to do that allow students choice and freedom with some structure so they can be successful in the makerspace area (Anderson, 2023). 
    Makerspaces are an easy, creative, and fun way to incorporate creating, making, and tinkering in the classroom. They can be as simple and cheap as you the teacher want them to be, making them accessible to any age and any classroom regardless of space or budget. The benefits of creating, innovating, collaborating, problem solving, and resilience building in our students' lives will be well worth the time creating makerspaces in the elementary school classrooms. 

References 
  • Anderson, M. (2023). Makerspace Activities for Elementary. STEM Activities for Kids. https://stemactivitiesforkids.com/2022/04/16/makerspace-activities-for-elementary/ 
  • Arts Integration. (2023). Makerspace Manual for K-12 Schools. Institute for Arts Integration and STEAM. https://artsintegration.com/makerspace-manual-for-k-12-schools/
  • Krueger, N. (2022, May 9). Create a School Makerspace in 3 Simple Steps. ISTE. https://www.iste.org/explore/classroom/create-school-makerspace-3-simple-steps
  • Robbin, A. (2020, August 24). The Benefits of a Makerspace in Schools. Graduate Programs for Educators. https://www.graduateprogram.org/2020/08/the-benefits-of-a-makerspace-in-schools/ 

Comments

  1. Anna,
    I really like your point that makerspaces do not have to be a physical space but can be a state of mind. When teachers recognize that they do not have to have a big space and fancy materials, they are freed to think through what kinds of projects their students can do, in any subject. Even the blocks center in a kindergarten class could be considered a makerspace because it is an open-ended area where students can create.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Anna, I like that you mentioned "too much freedom can be overwhelming" for the students. While there is a place for an open-ended task, freedom, and creativity, I think the safety within the engineering design process is that there are stages within the design framework as well. Once the teacher teaches the APIE process, students know that they have to analyze the issue, plan a solution or design, implement it, and then evaluate their solution. Teachers can also check in with the students at any stage they are at and help students process their thoughts. So it certainly is a shift and practice of this mindset that is part of the critical thinking and problem-solving aspect of STEM. I agree with you that they do not need expensive materials to get started on integrating STEM in the classroom.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Anna, I was happy to see that you included the idea of resiliency. While you noted a reference for that conclusion, I mentioned it as a hopeful outcome of this early introduction to STEM. In the demo yuotubes that i reviewed, several teachers commented that students do not show frustration when an idea fails, but instead, begin the process again. Because I have seen today's higher education students lack a handle on resiliency, hopefully this next generation of early STEM trained students will by default assume mastery of a resilient nature.



















































































































































































































































































































































































































    ReplyDelete
  4. Thank you for sharing your blog on makerspaces! One idea that you touched on in your post is providing students with guidance/expectations while also leaving activities open-ended. I know that I am personally a detail-oriented person, so I appreciate very specific instructions. However, other people are big-idea thinkers and like complete freedom on assignments. I think that the key to makerspaces is providing prompts and guidance that are both specified yet open-ended to appeal to both types of learners. Ideally, both detail-oriented and open-ended students will be stretched to think in new ways while still having the tools they need to succeed. I also love that you included the concern about funding in your post. Oftentimes, families and communities are more than willing to donate their materials to classrooms, the teacher just needs to ask. So often, it seems like money is the only way to improve education. However, with a little resourcefulness, classrooms can have access to the materials that will help their students grow and succeed.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment